By The SUN
![]() |
A High Court judge rejected all 4 applications by Filipinos to stop being sent back home |
Four Filipinos, three of them women, have become the latest
group of asylum-seekers to lose their bid to fight off deportation from Hong Kong .
The lone male in the group, Enrico K. Reyes, has overstayed
in the city for more than 13 years. Court of First Instance Judge Bruno Chan denied
his application for leave for a judicial review of the Immigration director’s decision rejecting his application for non-refoulement (or non-deportation) on Feb 6,
2017.
The next day, CFI Judge K.W. Lung also dismissed similar
applications by Maricar T. Villano, Rosemarie O. Padaco and Immaculada T. Millan.
Reyes, 54, visited Hong Kong
on Nov 12, 2005 and never left despite having permission to stay for only 14
days. A
After his arrest on Oct 17, 2008, he applied for
non-refoulement, saying a certain JA, an alleged New People’s Army guerilla,
threatened to kill him for canceling a PhP200,000 land sale.
Chan said Reyes had not given the court any additional facts
or representation that could justify his claim of being entitled to protection
under Hong Kong ’s Bill of Right. The judge
also said he was not satisfied that there was any prospect of success in Reyes’
application.
In her application, Villano claimed she would be harmed or killed
by a man who lent her PhP200,000 to get a job as a helper in Hong
Kong because she could not pay him back after she was fired. Fearing for her life, she claimed to have returned to Hong Kong as a visitor in late July 2014 but overstayed.
She applied for non-refoulement but was rejected on Jan 22 last year for the
reason that her claim was not substantiated.
Villano appealed to the Torture Claims Adjudication Board
but this was also dismissed in May last year.
![]() |
Call us now! |
Her application for leave was dismissed by Judge Lung who
said she did not have a reasonable chance of success in pursuing her claim.
Padaco, a visitor who arrived on Feb 24, 2011,
overstayed and was arrested by police on Apr 18 that year. She filed a torture
claim two days later but when the director rejected it on Nov 24, she disappeared.
She was re-arrested, but promptly applied for non-refoulement on Apr 24, 2013.
Her excuse was that a mayor’s son who had killed her nephew
in a roadside accident had threatened her life after she refused a bribe meant
to stop her telling the police about the incident.


The director dismissed her claim for being unsubstantiated,
so she appealed to the TCAB. Her appeal was also rejected so she applied for
leave for judicial review. As in the other cases, Judge Lung said her
application had no reasonable prospect of success.
For the same reason, the judge refused Millan’s bid for
leave.
Millan came twice to Hong Kong
to work as a domestic helper but was forced to return home after being fired.
She returned as a visitor in July 2016 but overstayed. She
surrendered to Immigration on Jul 25 that year, and immediately asked for non-refoulement,
saying she would be killed by a man for failing to repay a loan.
==
I-try mo ito, Kabayan: Kung interesado kang ma-contact ang mga advertiser namin dito, pindutin lang ang kanilang ad, at lalabas ang auto-dialer. Pindutin ulit upang tumawag. Hindi na kailangang pindutin ang mga numero.
I-try mo ito, Kabayan: Kung interesado kang ma-contact ang mga advertiser namin dito, pindutin lang ang kanilang ad, at lalabas ang auto-dialer. Pindutin ulit upang tumawag. Hindi na kailangang pindutin ang mga numero.