By Vir B. Lumicao
 |
The accused inside a police van as he arrived at Kowlon City Court (SCMP photo) |
An Indian engineer identified as the index patient in the
recent spread of the coronavirus variant was told that he faces an additional
charge of giving false information to an Immigration officer when he appeared
in Kowloon City court today, May 10.
Syed Mohammed Rizvi, 29, appeared before Magistrate Ada Yim on
a charge of lying to a medical officer when providing information about his
whereabouts between leaving his hotel quarantine and being found to carry the
variant on Apr 16.
He was supposed to appear with his Filipina girlfriend,
Victoria Marie A. Guadiz, 31, who is accused of failing to give information to
an authorized officer, but she was reportedly taken to Queen Elizabeth
Hospital this morning
with fever.
The prosecutor said Guadiz, a receptionist at a medical
clinic in Central, could be discharged by Thursday. Yim said that in that case,
the defendant should be called back to court on Friday so the charge could be read
to her.
The magistrate also ordered Rizvi remanded in custody until Jul 2, citing the severity of the charges against him, and his lack of family
ties in Hong Kong. She took note of the prosecutor's statement that the defendant would be charged with the more serious immigration offense at the next hearing.
The prosecutor told the court that Rizvi arrived from Dubai on Mar 19 and was
released from a 21-day quarantine on Apr 8. He then went to live with Guadiz in
a flat in Parkes Building on Jordan Road.
On Apr 16, he was found to carry a coronavirus variant. When
interviewed by a nurse at the hospital where he was taken about his whereabouts
on Apr 10-11, he reportedly said he just went around Jordan and Tsim Sha Tsui,
as well as Cheung Chau.
On Apr 28, after a Filipina domestic worker in Tung Chung
was found to carry a variant identical to his, Rizvi admitted he and Guadiz
visited Citygate mall on Apr 11 and dined in a restaurant elsewhere in Tung
Chung. They also went for a meal in Discovery
Bay.
Later it emerged that the pair had also been to several
places, said the prosecutor. These included a visit to Tong Fuk village on Apr
10, after which they spent the night at Novotel hotel in Tung Chung.
“Further, they visited D2’s (Guadiz) family on Apr 13 for a
gathering,” said the prosecutor.
The prosecutor said that they are considering laying further
charges of giving false information to immigration officers “on each
defendant.”
Rizvi allegedly provided “false information about his
contacts and whereabouts” when interviewed by an immigration officer. No
further details were given but he was given a copy of the particulars of the
charge.
In opposing bail, the
prosecution said the defendant lacked local ties. Although a Hong Kong ID card
holder, he is not a permanent resident and was merely visiting.
 |
Thousands of people were tested in Tung Chung where 3 residents were infected with the variant |
She also said that because of Rizvi’s false information,
more than 1,000 people residing in a housing block had to be sent to
quarantine.
Eight people found to carry the South African variant had
been linked to Rizvi, who is believed to have been infected during his 21-day
quarantine at Ramada Grand in Tsim Sha Tsui.
The mini-cluster includes, apart from the two, the helper in
Tung Chung, her employer and 10-month-old ward; two Filipina domestic helpers
who attended a gathering hosted by Guadiz’s brother; as well as her mother.
More than 2,000 residents of at least four housing blocks were moved to quarantine centers until the direct link among the eight infections was uncovered.
Rizvi pleaded to be allowed bail, saying he had two uncles
in Hong Kong with whom he could live while
waiting for his next court appointment. He also promised to surrender his
passport and report to police regularly if he is granted bail.
However, when Magistrate Yim asked him where he stayed after
being released from hospital, Rizvi said he stayed with a friend in Jordan.
He said he always stayed with his uncles whenever he came to
Hong Kong because they were his family, but he had to live in his friend’s flat
in Jordan because he was
planning to return to Dubai
and had left his luggage there.
The prosecution said police are still making further enquiry
and applied to obtain CCTV footages from the shops that Rizvi and his
girlfriend visited.
Rizvi said he needs a lawyer but Yim replied he does not
qualify for the Duty Lawyer Service so he would need to find a private counsel.
The magistrate set the trial from Jul 2 to 7 and told the
defendant to engage a lawyer.
Yim also told Rizvi he could apply for bail again on May 18,
during his bail review in the same court. Alternatively he could file a bail
application at the Court of First Instance.