By Vir B. Lumicao
 |
| Eastern magistrate denied application for bail pending appeal |
A Filipina helper accused of stealing a $500 banknote and a
lip balm from her employer was sentenced to 28 days in prison on Jun 7 after an
Eastern court magistrate found her guilty of theft.
Despite the setback, Margie Lotino’s defense counsel quickly
began the process of appeal. He applied for bail on the defendant’s behalf so
an appeal against her
conviction could be launched at the High Court.
The prosecutor, defense lawyer, court interpreters, agency
representative and a Consulate officer who had stood by Lotino during the six
days of trial, returned to the court for the bail application just minutes
after Magistrate Simon Ho meted out the sentence.
But Ho rejected the application, saying, “I cannot see any
reason why I should grant bail”.
Ho then threw a glance at Lotino, who was crying
inconsolably.
The magistrate said he gave weight to the prosecution’s evidence
and also on the defendant’s statement to
police in which she admitted her guilt. He also said the sentence he imposed
was light, considering that the case involved a serious breach of trust.
Lotino’s trial was halted early on, when the magistrate decided
to call six police officers to the witness stand to respond to the defendant’s
complaint that they had made her strip down to her underwear during three
separate interrogations.
The Filipino court interpreter was also called to explain
why she allegedly told the defendant to admit the offense in her police statement.
Ho said the police witnesses were reliable and honest, and
the court interpreter was independent and accurate and would not have sided
with any of the parties in the case.
In the previous hearing on May 16, Ho rejected an attempt by
the defense to include the alleged repeated body-searches and other police misconduct
in Lotino’s evidence. He also cleared the officers of misconduct.
On Apr 20, Lotino accused her female employer, who is a
teacher and wife of a traffic officer, of framing her up. She said she signed a
statement admitting the offenses because she was cold, hungry, fatigued from
lack of sleep and under intense pressure from body searches and interrogations
lasting more than 14 hours before she was freed on bail.
She said during the ordeal the police refused to give her
water or make phone calls to the Consulate or to Technic Employment Service
Centre Ltd, which deployed her.
Technic staff Melanie Fisher testified on May 16, saying Lotino
went straight to the agency distraught after being released by the police. The
next morning, she took Lotino to the Consulate’s assistance to nationals
section to seek help.
