![]() |
| Illustrative photo created with deevid.ai |
A Filipina domestic helper on trial over the theft of a pair of used sunglasses, one tube of three-year-old MAC lipstick and one unfinished tube of hair mascara, was found guilty today at the Eastern Court and sentenced to four months imprisonment.
Magistrate Tobias Cheng said in giving his verdict that he found
enough contradictions in the testimony of Mary June Valerio, 29 years old, to
reach his conclusion.
Valerio had denied stealing the items from Nanami Harrison,
the wife of her employer, at their residence at Arezzo, 33 Seymour Road,
Mid-Levels, Hong Kong between an unknown date in March 2026 and June 27, 2026.
![]() |
| Basahin ang detalye! |
She was charged with violation of section 9 of the Theft
Ordinance.
Cheng noted the good relationship between
Valerio and Harrison, the possibilty that the stolen items may have been thrown
by the employer into garbage bags as the family was packing up to move out of
the flat and Harrison always misplacing her things, but these did not outweigh
the fact that the items were found in Valerio’s belongings.
“The defendant presented contradictory evidence,” he said.
Cheng said contrary to the defense claim, the pair of sunglasses
was in good condition and can have a resale value of $1,500. The hair mascara
and lipstick were half used but had no obvious damage and still usable, he
added.
In mitigation, Valerio’s lawyer said the conviction is already
a severe punishment as she can longer find a job in Hong Kong.
But Cheng cited previous cases in which the punishment was
seven to nine months in prison. He said he considered a suspended sentence, but
did not find it appropriate.

